so, do you think he should have been fired, or does the punishment fit the crime?
My opinion? I think after the announcement Jim Tressel was screaming "Are you fucking kidding me!"
Tressel "resigned" after it was discovered that he knew a few players had received tattoos and cash for memorabilia and he failed to report it to the university. When asked he said that he didn't know about it, but later emails surfaced that proved he did and failed to tell the university or discipline the players.
In this case
Urban claimed he knew of the 2012 domestic violence incident but didn't report it because no charges were filed. Despite that he still hired him in 2014 and claimed ignorance to any events after that.
The results of the investigation proved that he had a reasonable purpose to believe the accusations and should have notified the university and fired him. It also proved that he knew the coach took dick picks in the Whitehouse and various places around campus yet still didn't report it or fire him. It also proved that he knew the coach took recruiting trips where he took highschool coaches to strip clubs yet didn't report it or fire him.
They both claimed ignorance. The only difference between the two besides the fact that Urbans accusations were far more serious than some stupid golden pants for a tattoo trade, was the smoking gun of evidence that he knew and therefore lied. This is likely why once the news broke urban pulled a Hillary and started deleting texts and emails prior to handing over devices.
At the end of the day if people look at this on its face, it's blatantly obvious that Urban committed the same infractions that Tressel did with the turning a blind eye, ignoring it, and lying about knowing. Except Urban did it with far more agregious issues than tressels pants scandal. If even half of the same standards were upheld against urban as they were tressel its clear to see that he should have been fired.
However, while it's clear to pretty much everyone that he lied and that there is no way in hell he couldn't have known, the smoking gun emails that prove such, and got tressel fired, is lacking. This allowed the university just enough wiggle room to save their beloved coaches ass. The only loose end was they had to do something so they suspended him for three games.
In my opinion. They got him on what they could get him for absent a smoking gun. However despite the lack of that smoking gun its still pretty obvious what happened so they needed to run some serious cover to help him out. Hence the university making claims on his behalf thst he misspoke at the media day event.