- 308
- 65
Take a long look at the way you hunt, the distances you generally get shots and and the terrain. If you don't have a muzzleloader start there with a good inline. If you do then you can get much more bang for your buck out of a straight wall cartridge rifle than a shotgun unless you don't have a good one.
Look into 44 mag, 444 marlin, 45-70, 450 bushmaster, 350 legend best options out there unless you reload and then look into the 357max
I run 1.25-4x on my muzzy and rifles. Plenty of zoom for out to 200 yards and quick up close.
44mag in rifle won't gain much over the pistol outside of being easier to steady. Might gain a little distance but I don't think it will be substantially more than a pistol. My neighbor has 44mag rifle and looking at 450 or 350. He was not happy with results this year. Not quite enough ka-pow he said.
If shotgun, I'd lean towards Savage 220 or 212 bolt action. They are another fan favorite. I have the 220 but keep kicking around the idea of a 450. No reason why other than an excuse to buy another gun. My 220 has killed everything it pointed at.
I do have a Benelli Montefeltro I use for duck/goose so I don’t really “need” another. I was originally leaning towards another 12g particularly a combo as a back up to my Benelli as well as a spare to get my brother in law back into some duck hunting