talltine 8 shed

Found a shed from a buck we call talltine 8 . We think he was 2.5 in this pic in 2010. What do you guys think? The shed was from 2010 but was in great shape. My Granddaughter Kayleigh is the antler model. Jared saw him one time this year and he is a dandy 140" or better, he has 12" or 13" tines...