Polymer frames
- Thread starter FredT
- Start date
Buckmaster
Senior Member
Interesting topic. From what I've seen they are pretty durable on physical and mechanical testing procedures. Blowing one up on the otherhand....I don't know.
Once....Glock 40. Watched it happen at the range. It was a reload believed to have a double charge. Mag blew out, slide and controls all blew out, no major injuries.
Ohiosam
*Supporting Member*
Don't think I know anyone that has blown one up. Know a few guys that have blown up revolvers and 1911 usually double charges.
Fred you know way more then I but don't most pistols that aren't blowback actions lock the barrel to the slide similar to a 1911? If so if both the barrel and slide are metal isn't the frame material somewhat irrelevant?
Fred you know way more then I but don't most pistols that aren't blowback actions lock the barrel to the slide similar to a 1911? If so if both the barrel and slide are metal isn't the frame material somewhat irrelevant?
Here are some pics of an FNP-45 that let loose. First pic is the case showing no bulge. Next shows primer not flattened. Next shows the case failure.
Two pics of the results.
Load was 5.8 grains of Unique, 228 grain cast bullet, Remington large pistol primer, Winchester case.
Two pics of the results.
Load was 5.8 grains of Unique, 228 grain cast bullet, Remington large pistol primer, Winchester case.
Must have fired out of battery. Never heard of a FN doing that????
Actually looks like it has happened a few times...
http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2012/02/27/fn-five-seven-kaboom/
http://consumerist.com/2008/05/five-seven-gun-blows-up-in-owners-hand-manufacturer-indifferent.html
Seems like all 5.7's though
I have never seen a pistol KABOOM that wasn't a reload or stove pipe.
Actually looks like it has happened a few times...
http://www.thefirearmblog.com/blog/2012/02/27/fn-five-seven-kaboom/
http://consumerist.com/2008/05/five-seven-gun-blows-up-in-owners-hand-manufacturer-indifferent.html
Seems like all 5.7's though
I have never seen a pistol KABOOM that wasn't a reload or stove pipe.
Last edited:
Ohiosam
*Supporting Member*
I bet that stung! I agree, it fired out of battery.
So now the question is: would a steel or alloy frame have provided the shooter with more protect? Probably.
So now the question is: would a steel or alloy frame have provided the shooter with more protect? Probably.
Milo
Tatonka guide.
- 8,184
- 157
primer dimple seems wierd to me...seems like i remember another smaller ring generally shows around the primer hit ..that failure is pretty bad and definetly out of battery. how many times has the shell been reloaded fred? also i would be curious to throw a caliper on the shell and check if it was out of round any. Were you for sure in factory case length spec?