Welcome to TheOhioOutdoors
Wanting to join the rest of our members? Login or sign up today!
Login / Join

Why I hate Fishing in Ohio

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
38,841
260
As most of you know I grew up in Alabama and Mississippi. I belong to a few outdoor related facebook pages for those states and see people posting pictures all the time. When you grew up catching fish like this almost every trip it makes Ohio look like a mud puddle. I was floored the first time i saw a stringer of crappie off an inland lake in Ohio. I Couldn't believe people were keeping them... Makes a fella miss home.
 

Attachments

  • 12919842_10153448544627155_6551301969141409707_n.jpg
    12919842_10153448544627155_6551301969141409707_n.jpg
    130 KB · Views: 286
  • 12803102_10153445456942155_4634543876919422819_n.jpg
    12803102_10153445456942155_4634543876919422819_n.jpg
    59.9 KB · Views: 333
  • 12376659_10201517661501390_6003152491934002498_n.jpg
    12376659_10201517661501390_6003152491934002498_n.jpg
    117.5 KB · Views: 340
  • 12924475_10208599754093201_3313660375151278618_n.jpg
    12924475_10208599754093201_3313660375151278618_n.jpg
    72.3 KB · Views: 340
  • 12472649_10208589439955354_1037626200568956098_n.jpg
    12472649_10208589439955354_1037626200568956098_n.jpg
    106.1 KB · Views: 290
  • 12670698_10208589439715348_4484490069409574459_n.jpg
    12670698_10208589439715348_4484490069409574459_n.jpg
    87.4 KB · Views: 328
  • 12932780_10208589440035356_3427627947186491591_n.jpg
    12932780_10208589440035356_3427627947186491591_n.jpg
    139.7 KB · Views: 330
  • 12512415_10153440646707155_4324544905770281735_n.jpg
    12512415_10153440646707155_4324544905770281735_n.jpg
    191.1 KB · Views: 327

"J"

Git Off My Lawn
Supporting Member
56,738
274
North Carolina
I'll agree with you 100% on this... I've fished down south out west and all over Ohio/pa and some in New York and Ohio is a far cry from most of these states.... But fishing in Ohio will make you a better angler if you can catch them here on a consistent basis you are doing something.... And I'm talking quality fish here not dinks....
 

giles

Cull buck specialist
Supporting Member
Yup! You nailed it, Ohio fishing sucks. I never realized it until I left. It has everything it needs except for people that understand what it takes to keep a great fishery great.
 
Last edited:

jagermeister

Dignitary Member
Supporting Member
18,060
223
Ohio
Yup! You nailed it, Ohio fishing sucks. I never realized it until I left. It has everything it needs except for people that understand what it takes to keep a great fishery great.
You guys are nuts. I don't see any walleye or yellow perch in any of those pics, Joe. I like catching slab crappie and brim too, but you can find em in Ohio if you look hard enough. Plenty of 13+" crappie and 8+" bluegill to be caught around here. But where down south can you go catch 12 lb walleye on the regular??? That's right, fuggin nowhere. Ohio fishing does not suck.
 

moundhill

Senior Member
Supporting Member
5,327
103
Hebbardsville..
I've always wanted to go down south on a fishing trip. Mostly smallmouth. I think J should arrange a TOO down south trip and do some fishing.
 

giles

Cull buck specialist
Supporting Member
You guys are nuts. I don't see any walleye or yellow perch in any of those pics, Joe. I like catching slab crappie and brim too, but you can find em in Ohio if you look hard enough. Plenty of 13+" crappie and 8+" bluegill to be caught around here. But where down south can you go catch 12 lb walleye on the regular??? That's right, fuggin nowhere. Ohio fishing does not suck.

I only see that in the fishery that is shared up north. It's also a body of water that the fish can "get away" from anglers. Most other bodies of water don't get that luxury.
 

"J"

Git Off My Lawn
Supporting Member
56,738
274
North Carolina
Erie is a rarity for Ohio in that it's an amazing fishery that can't compare too the rest of the state....
 

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
38,841
260
You guys are nuts. I don't see any walleye or yellow perch in any of those pics, Joe. I like catching slab crappie and brim too, but you can find em in Ohio if you look hard enough. Plenty of 13+" crappie and 8+" bluegill to be caught around here. But where down south can you go catch 12 lb walleye on the regular??? That's right, fuggin nowhere. Ohio fishing does not suck.

So you're saying just because you can catch some walleye in lake Erie, and if you hunt and peck for a decent lake just to fish for hours on end you can catch a few decent sized Bluegill or Crappie so Ohio's fishing rocks. Name me one place in Ohio you can go through 200 minnows before lunch and fill a 48 quart cooler with 12+ inch Crappie. Nowhere. Whereas back home when they're spawning I've seen a colored fellow catch a cooler full out of a flooded ditch along the road.

The reservoir down the road from my house has a slot limit on walleye, never caught one even close because people keep everything. You can however catch plenty of 6 inch crappie and white bass, dink gills, and yellow bellies until you're sick of catching what I consider bait.

Don't forget that Mississippi and Alabama also have the Gulf. Similar to how Ohio has the lake. But you know what you can catch in the gulf? Way more than some walleye and perch. You can catch Reds, speckled trout, like 25 species of jacks, Mackerels, angle fish, baracuda, black bass, rock bass, bluefish, bonefish, black drum, red drum, flounder, like 20 species of grouper, mullet, kroker and the list goes on..

Inshore you can catch a crazy variety of sunfish and bluegill, black and white crappies, spotted bass, striped bass, 4-5 varieties of catfish, gar both alligator and longnose, buffalo, spoonbill catfish and on and on. Hell fishing for the invasive snakehead offers some explosive fishing that will rival even largemouth.

Combine all that with the amount of water, lakes, rivers, backwater, swamps, and streams, and a really long growing and spawning season with mild winters and you have heaven on earth for fishing. Fishing in Ohio doesn't come close to holding a candle to wetting a line in the deep south. Not even the best day on the lake fishing walleye or perch.
 

Joel

Senior Member
3,049
113
Centerburg, Ohio
I've lived here and fished here all my life. I'm a little jealous of southern states after seeing those pics though. I've had a few good fishing trips over the years but normally if I catch a few keepers and a couple small ones i feel pretty accomplished.
 

giles

Cull buck specialist
Supporting Member
It is t limited to the south. Idaho, Minnesota, Dakota's...they all offer some great fishing also. Min has some very productive walleye and yellow perch fishing.
 

jagermeister

Dignitary Member
Supporting Member
18,060
223
Ohio
I'm not saying Ohio is the best. Just simply stating that it's a great place to fish, just like many other states in this country. There's a reason why people are towing boats from all over the country to Ohio to fish for perch and walleye.
 

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
38,841
260
I'm not saying Ohio is the best. Just simply stating that it's a great place to fish, just like many other states in this country. There's a reason why people are towing boats from all over the country to Ohio to fish for perch and walleye.

It's not even close to a great place to fish man. The inland streams are so polluted with farm and city run of they can't sustain any decent fish populations except carp. The reservoirs are pretty much overfished bowls that lack cover and suitable bedding for breeding. The trash fish like white bass, carp and suckers dominate the waters and muddy the headwaters so bad they're not a renewable fishery. Most of them are located around populated areas and are overfished like mad.

Lake Erie doesn't carry the rest of the state and make Ohio a good fishery.
 

Jackalope

Dignitary Member
Staff member
38,841
260
O well Joe. There's always deer hunting... lol

Pope and Young for 2015 ranked Ohio the number 5 state and Mississippi number 6 for the best whitetail states. And the waterfowl hunting is so good I doubt even Jaegermeister would argue that one. Then there's turkeys and hogs galore.
 

jagermeister

Dignitary Member
Supporting Member
18,060
223
Ohio
It's not even close to a great place to fish man. The inland streams are so polluted with farm and city run of they can't sustain any decent fish populations except carp. The reservoirs are pretty much overfished bowls that lack cover and suitable bedding for breeding. The trash fish like white bass, carp and suckers dominate the waters and muddy the headwaters so bad they're not a renewable fishery.

Lake Erie doesn't carry the rest of the state and make Ohio a good fishery.
You're delusional my friend.