I'm a Pirate fan and love the rivalry with the Reds. I dislike most reds players until they retire. Then I reflect and appreciate what they did. I always respect their game though. Great example is Eric Davis. Man did I hate him when he played. But, dang was he good.
Current guy that drives me nuts? Joey Votto! But damn he's good too!
Anyway... Pete Rose was one of the best no matter what team he played for (reds, Phillies, expos). I think he should be let in.
In my opinion it should be a fan vote, players association vote, or media vote. No way it should be just the commissioner with the only say.