Every time I see this deer he looks different. He looks solid in this photo..... I'd say he's def 4.... I have photos of him last year I believe too....
How big u think he is.... I think I might struggle the next time I see him. The last time was from a distance....
Looks like the 8 I passes last year. If he would of had the mass that deer has I would of killed him. He looks good. I always second guess myself hope you get a better look at him.
After reevaluating this buck my original guess is more in line with your 05 buck IMO. I'd say this buck grosses closer to 128 due to less mass and length than your 05 buck.
I'd guess 120 - 125. His symmetry is very nice, so very little in the way of deductions. He doesn't appear to be quite the caliber of the deer you took in 05. They look a lot alike though.