I am NOT the expert here. I looked into the Black Gold line of sights though and was impressed. Never ended up buying one or using one though. I also looked really hard at the Spothogg sights and really liked them as well. They are built like tanks. Ended up getting an Armortech simply because I felt it was comparable and I got a great buy on a "used" on which had never been used off AT. If budget is a concern, I also run a Sword Twilight on my old bow. It has been pretty good to me. Difference being the pins do not adjust quite as easily. Pins are a bit dainty compared to Spothogg or Excel Armortech. I have had them bend a little dragging it in/out of the woods/brush. I put a lot of hours on stand so I do feel mine gets some abuse compared to a guy who spends more time at the range or fewer trips in/out of the woods. Abuse is probably harsh, but wear and tear from field usage is probably more accurate. I don't think you could go wrong with any of them. Plenty of guys out there shooting "cheapy" sights and still killing deer. If your shots are 30yds or 40yds and under, I don't think there will be a massive difference. That said, I exerted a ton of time and research before I bought mine. I know what you are going through. lmao