I'm sure he was over 200 dressed. You should have weighed him. My buddy and I love weighing our deer. I thought the buck I shot this year was 140 tops, so did my buddy. Scale said he was 166. I shot one when I was young, in Jersey. Called my buddy to come help me get him out. Needless to say, he said I was overreacting, and there was no way the deer was 170 like I claimed. They never get that big in Jersey. He crapped when he saw him. But we never imagined he would tip the scales at 190. You never know unless you weigh them.